top of page
  • Foodie Nation

Orange Custard Pie Recipe


Evaporated Milk - 24 oz Condensed Milk - 395 g Fresh Orange Juice - 1/4 cup ANGOSTURA® orange bitters - 2 tsp ANGOSTURA® aromatic bitters - 1 tsp Instant Powdered Milk - ½ cup Eggs - 4 large

Orange Sauce Fresh Orange Juice - 1 cup ANGOSTURA® orange bitters - 2 tsp Granulated Sugar - 2 tbsp


  1. Preheat oven to 350°F.

  2. Add evaporated milk, condensed milk, orange juice, orange bitters, aromatic bitters, powdered milk and eggs to blender and blend well.

  3. Pour into a 10” by 10” greased baking dish, individual ramekins or glass dishes.

  4. Place into a hot water bath.

  5. Bake for 1 hour.

  6. Heat small sauce pan over medium heat.

  7. Add ingredients for orange sauce to sauce pan and simmer until thick.

  8. Set aside.

  9. Allow custard to cool before slicing.

  10. Pour sauce over custard and enjoy!

*DISCLAIMER: This recipe includes paid advertisements for ANGOSTURA® aromatic bitters and ANGOSTURA® orange bitters.

Foodie Nation Instagram @foodienationtt ig

Join our mailing list to see our latest posts 1st!

bottom of page